This time it's different. In past Next Iron Chefs, the show has been structured with two competitions, the first one, producing a winner that would have an advantage to the next competition where someone would be eliminated. In this Super Chef version, there was a drawing of straws (actually in this case, matches) for the advantage, then an competition, then the two lowest scores (or in this case, the team of two) had a cook-off against the other.
I'm not sure what I think yet. It's a bit disconcerting to go to the cook-off at the end and to hear the other contestants cheering their competitors on. In the past, partiuclarly last year, this has been a show of flinging elbows, of hurt feelings, of ruthless ambition. Perhaps that will still come later. But these are the most qualified contestants that they've ever brought together for this show. It says a lot for the franchise that they would be willing to compete for this prize. I guess my question for the future would be: How would you top it? Should you try?
Back to this season for a moment. My favorite is still Anne Burrell. Since Cat Cora has apparently is no longer on Iron Chef, the franchise badly needs a woman representative. (And why no explanation about Cora's exit? Is it just simply that she got tired of it, too busy? That would be what I think, but I don't know.) And Burrell has the history and the tradition, as she was Batali's sous chef on this show for many years. It just feels like the right choice to me.
However, there are many other candidates and I might change my mind as the season goes on, although I doubt it. So far Chef Guarnaschelli is the one standing out as the chef who has a hard time dealing with stressful situations. Get Chef Irvine in a competition where he has to build his own fire, and he just commandeers as much kindling as he can. Chef Guarnaschelli was just a few degrees north of a meltdown. It will be interesting to see how that plays out. She's an established personality on the network, an acclaimed chef. How personally interesting will she let herself be in this show?