There's two things I concluded this week, always subject to change, but this is what I think right now:
1) Personal essays are my favorite things to read.
2) What makes a writer fun to read is their prevailing spirit behind their words. It's especially true, I think, in memoirs, which can be such a treat if the writer is funny and smart and self-effacing even in the midst of recording their own anecdotes. But if the writer is, in my opinion, whiny or clueless or self-congratulatory, well, then the read becomes more like watching a house burn down--horrifying and fascinating at the same time, while there's this compelling, simultaneous urge to run away and to do something to make it stop immediately, while all the while knowing that it's hopeless, and you just wished that you had never been a witness to the event.
This is the second book of essays that I've read by Nick Hornby, and I wish I had one to read every week. Songbook is, as you might imagine, all about music. Each essay is about one particular song that Hornby loves. His particular passion is pop music. It's something we share. And it is a funny thing to love, because as Hornby notes in his book, it can often be silly, except for when it's not. (And it's here that I make a mental note: Buy Aimee Mann and Michael Penn. Invest in intelligent pop music.) It's a very funny thing. I love music, but I've quit listening to it. I used to know a fair amount about it. When I was in college, I was a d.j. at a 90 watt freeform station that you could hear if you were on a certain block on a certain side of the street. But I learned a lot about music and I got to listen to a lot of music. I always thought that I majored in radio and somehow got a degree in French and English. But I didn't keep up with the music. Part of the sadness that I felt reading this book was that I didn't know any of the current references. It's expensive to keep up. You can't really stay educated by listening to the radio, I think, but that might not be true, because I just listen to ballgames and NPR. But it's also that, as Hornby says, pop music is supposedly dead, even though there's still people doing it, they're not getting the attention of the "Yesterdays" of yesteryear.
I did know (and agree) with a lot of his choices from his youth. Rod Stewart's "Mama, You've been on My Mind" has always been a favorite of mine as well, along with all his old catalog. To me, what happened to his professional career has always been a cautionary tale, and I was interested to hear that Elvis Costello wanted to take him under his wing and produce a record for him, and that Hornby shared this same dream (and I wish he had said what songs he had in mind for Stewart to record.) And I loved what Hornby had to say about Jackson Browne--that during the 70s when all the girls (including me) had his albums, Hornby actively avoided his music. And it was only in his later life, after a divorce where he had worn out his cache of divorce music (Springsteen's "Tunnel of Love" and Derek and the Domino's "Layla") that Hornby finally turned to Browne, and realized that this is a man who wrote beautiful ballads, and that David Lindley is a briliant accompanist. Hornby talked about being a bigot, of disliking Browne for his bowl cut hair style, and for missing something wise and beautfiul, that he had to grow up before he could appreciate it. They're thoughtful pieces that stick with you and remind you of how important songs can be in life.